Tax fraud investigations have uncovered a scheme in which a Chinese company fraudulently evaded over Ksh. 1 billion in taxes by channeling income through shell companies to accounts in China.
The fraudulent scheme, known as the ‘missing trader’ tax evasion tactic, was highlighted in an appeal by China Communications Construction Company Ltd to the Tax Appeals Tribunal (TAT). The company sought to overturn a tax assessment of Ksh. 1,047,557,661.
READ ALSO: Migrated Legacy System Taxpayer Ledger Balances
China Communications Construction Company Ltd, a major state-owned, publicly traded multinational based in China, specializes in designing and constructing infrastructure such as highways, bridges, tunnels, railways, airports, marine ports, and oil platforms.
On August 9, 2024, the TAT upheld the tax assessment and rejected the appeal, following KRA’s submissions filed on May 25, 2023. The Commissioner for Investigations & Enforcement was the respondent in the case.
The KRA audit, conducted on February 3, 2023, revealed that the company had inflated its VAT input claims by using fictitious invoices from non-existent or fraudulently registered companies. This tactic was used to reduce tax liabilities.
The audit demonstrated that China Communications Construction Company Ltd claimed VAT for goods and services that were never supplied. Evidence showed that the company claimed inflated VAT from six fraudulent firms:
- Dial an Errand Ltd: Ksh. 638,251,386
- Haru Limited: Ksh. 156,532,074
- Njafos Holdings Ltd: Ksh. 256,932,293
- Masaviru Investment Limited: Ksh. 157,035,000
- Math and Kith Investment Company Limited: Ksh. 213,448,586
- Lunza Solutions Limited: Ksh. 221,061,000
These shell companies, which had no known physical addresses, were part of a broader network involving tier 3 shell companies. These included Benlaz Company Ltd, Hao Yuan International Company Limited, Colila Ltd, Crystal Touch Company Ltd, Akubi Ltd, Homematt Ltd, and Ujenzi Suppliers Ltd. The tier 3 companies also claimed VAT from tier 4 shell companies, such as Papaya Company Ltd.
For example, Njafos Holdings Limited had discrepancies between the account signatory, George Makuthi Nderitu, and the registered director, Simon Musyimi Musyoki. Similarly, Suleiman Odhiambo Oganga, the registered director of Benlaz Company, claimed his identity had been fraudulently used, and Lassina Coulibaly, the registered director of Colila Limited, had left Kenya in 2006. Crystal Touch Limited had been struck from the Registrar of Companies’ records by that time.
The investigation revealed that shell companies received payments for construction materials but immediately transferred the funds to USD accounts, which were then wired overseas, including to China.
The Tribunal concluded that the elaborate tax avoidance scheme was proven, as KRA’s assertions were not contested, and the company did not provide evidence to counter these claims. The Tribunal observed that the transactions did not represent genuine commercial activity but were part of a deliberate scheme to evade taxes in Kenya.
The consistent use of similar fraudulent practices among various entities indicated a well-orchestrated effort to avoid tax obligations.
Source: Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA)
Matthews Ohotto is an Online Tutorials Blogger with over 10 years experience in Researching, Writing and Publishing the most comprehensive: Latest iTax Tutorials, Latest eTIMS Tutorials, Popular Blog Posts and Latest KRA Updates in Kenya at CYBER.CO.KE on a day to day basis, keeping you informed and engaged with insightful blog content. He is a holder of Bachelor of Business Information Technology (BBIT) Degree from Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology (JKUAT) with key interest in Digital Business Innovation. Need Help? Send an Email to: [email protected] today.
ARE YOU LOOKING FOR KRA SERVICES IN KENYA? SUBMIT YOUR REQUEST ONLINE FOR KRA INDIVIDUAL SERVICES, KRA NON INDIVIDUAL SERVICES AND KRA RETURNS SERVICES WITH EASE. GET STARTED NOW!
SUBMIT YOUR REQUEST ONLINE FOR KRA INDIVIDUAL SERVICES USING CYBER.CO.KE
 KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register and get a New KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for KRA PIN Registration. |
|
KRA PIN RETRIEVAL |
Are you looking to Retrieve and get a Lost KRA PIN Certificate? We are here and ready to assist you with Retrieval of KRA PIN Certificate. Fill and submit your request online for KRA PIN Retrieval. |
|
KRA PIN UPDATE |
Are you looking to Update an Old KRA PIN Number on iTax (KRA Portal)? We are here and ready to assist you with Update of KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for KRA PIN Update. |
|
KRA PIN CHANGE OF EMAIL ADDRESS |
Are you looking to Change the Email Address linked to KRA PIN Number on iTax? We are here and ready to assist you. Fill and submit your request online for KRA PIN Change of Email Address. |
|
REFUGEE KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register KRA PIN Number for Refugee? We are here and ready to assist you. Fill and submit your request online for Refugee KRA PIN Registration. |
|
FOREIGNER KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register KRA PIN Number for Foreigner? We are here and ready to assist you. Fill and submit your request online for Foreigner KRA PIN Registration. |
SUBMIT YOUR REQUEST ONLINE FOR KRA NON INDIVIDUAL SERVICES USING CYBER.CO.KE
 SELF HELP GROUP (SHG) KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register Self Help Group (SHG) KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of Self Help Group (SHG) KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for Self Help Group (SHG) KRA PIN Registration. |
|
COMPANY KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register Company KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of Company KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for Company KRA PIN Registration. |
|
PARTNERSHIP KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register Partnership KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of Partnership KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for Partnership KRA PIN Registration. |
|
SOCIETY KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register Society KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of Society KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for Society KRA PIN Registration. |
|
ASSOCIATION KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register Association KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of Association KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for Association KRA PIN Registration. |
|
NGO KRA PIN REGISTRATION |
Are you looking to Register NGO KRA PIN Number? We are here and ready to assist you with Registration of NGO KRA PIN Number. Fill and submit your request online for NGO KRA PIN Registration. |
SUBMIT YOUR REQUEST ONLINE FOR KRA RETURNS SERVICES USING CYBER.CO.KE
 KRA NIL RETURNS FILING |
Are you looking to file KRA Nil Returns? We are here and ready to assist you with Filing of KRA Nil Returns. Fill and submit your request online for KRA Nil Returns Filing. |
|
KRA EMPLOYMENT RETURNS FILING |
Are you looking to file KRA Employment Returns? We are here and ready to assist you with Filing of KRA Employment Returns. Fill and submit your request online for KRA Employment Returns Filing. |
|
TURNOVER TAX (TOT) RETURNS FILING |
Are you looking to file Turnover Tax (TOT) Returns? We are here and ready to assist you with Filing of Turnover Tax (TOT) Returns. Fill and submit your request online for Turnover Tax (TOT) Returns Filing. |
|
MONTHLY RENTAL INCOME (MRI) RETURNS FILING |
Are you looking to file Monthly Rental Income (MRI) Returns? We are here and ready to assist you with Filing of Monthly Rental Income (MRI) Returns. Fill and submit your request online for Monthly Rental Income (MRI) Returns Filing. |
|
PAY AS YOU EARN (PAYE) RETURNS FILING |
Are you looking to file Pay As You Earn (PAYE) Returns? We are here and ready to assist you with Filing of Pay As You Earn (PAYE) Returns. Fill and submit your request online for Pay As You Earn (PAYE) Returns Filing. |
|
VALUE ADDED TAX (VAT) RETURNS FILING |
Are you looking to file Value Added Tax (VAT) Returns? We are here and ready to assist you with Filing of Value Added Tax (VAT) Returns. Fill and submit your request online for Value Added Tax (VAT) Returns Filing. |